35 attractions, parks and places to visit in and around Shelter Island · updated November 2026
The best things to do in Shelter Island are Orient Beach State Park, Railroad Museum of Long Island and Cedar Island Light. Within 15 miles of Shelter Island you will find 6 museums & galleries, 10 historic sites & landmarks, 4 parks & gardens, 10 nature reserves & natural wonders, 2 theaters & public art, 3 golf, marinas & outdoor sports. 4 of them are free. The best time to visit Shelter Island is June to September.
Advertisement
Shelter Island travel guide: quick facts
Top attraction
Orient Beach State Park (State park)
Places to visit
35 within 15 mi
Free things to do
4
Kid-friendly places
7
Best time to visit
June to September
Location
Suffolk County, New York
Top 10 things to do in Shelter Island
Orient Beach State Park
State park · 5.4 mi N
Orient Beach State Park is a 363-acre (1.47 km2) state park located in Southold, New York. The park is situated at the tip of the North Fork of Long Island.
Long Beach, located within the park, was designated a National…
The Railroad Museum of Long Island – also known by its reporting mark, RMLI – is a railway museum based on the North Fork of Long Island, in Suffolk County, New York, United States. It has two locations: the main…
Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum is dedicated to the port town's past within the American whaling industry. It houses the largest collection of whaling equipment in the state of New York.
Orient Long Beach Bar Light is a lighthouse off Orient, New York. It was originally a screwpile lighthouse that was later converted to concrete caisson foundation. Its early appearance as a screwpile lighthouse gave it…
The Parrish Art Museum is an art museum designed by Herzog & de Meuron Architects and located in Water Mill, New York, whereto it moved in 2012 from Southampton Village. The museum focuses extensively on work by artists…
Dia Bridgehampton is a museum in Bridgehampton, New York run by the Dia Art Foundation. Opened in 1983 as the Dan Flavin Art Institute, the building was renovated by Dia, under the direction of minimalist sculptor Dan…
Elizabeth Alexandra Morton National Wildlife Refuge
Wildlife refuge · 5.2 mi SW
The Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge is a 187-acre (76 ha) National Wildlife Refuge in Noyack, New York. Much of the refuge is situated on a peninsula surrounded by Noyack and Little Peconic bays. The refuge…
Horton Point Light is a lighthouse on the north side of Eastern Long Island, New York in the hamlet of Southold. The lighthouse and the grounds surrounding it are under the supervision of the Town of Southold Park…
The mill cottage on the Lion Gardiner farm at 36 James Lane on the landmarked East Hampton Village green has become a museum displaying 19th and early-20th-century landscape paintings. It is a contributing structure on…
Museums and art galleries near Shelter Island: there are 6 on our list. The most popular is Railroad Museum of Long Island (4.6 mi NW), followed by Sag Harbor Whaling Museum, Parrish Art Museum and Dia Bridgehampton.
Railroad Museum of Long Island
Museum · 4.6 mi NW
The Railroad Museum of Long Island – also known by its reporting mark, RMLI – is a railway museum based on the North Fork of Long Island, in Suffolk County, New York, United States. It has two locations: the main…
Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum is dedicated to the port town's past within the American whaling industry. It houses the largest collection of whaling equipment in the state of New York.
The Parrish Art Museum is an art museum designed by Herzog & de Meuron Architects and located in Water Mill, New York, whereto it moved in 2012 from Southampton Village. The museum focuses extensively on work by artists…
Dia Bridgehampton is a museum in Bridgehampton, New York run by the Dia Art Foundation. Opened in 1983 as the Dan Flavin Art Institute, the building was renovated by Dia, under the direction of minimalist sculptor Dan…
The mill cottage on the Lion Gardiner farm at 36 James Lane on the landmarked East Hampton Village green has become a museum displaying 19th and early-20th-century landscape paintings. It is a contributing structure on…
The Halsey House is a historic house converted into a museum, in Southampton, New York. It was built circa 1683 by Thomas Halsey Jr., the son of pioneer Thomas Halsey Sr.
The house has been restored, and is open to the…
Historic sites, monuments and landmarks near Shelter Island: there are 10 on our list. The most popular is Cedar Island Light (2.1 mi SE), followed by Orient Long Beach Bar Light, Horton Point Light and Plum Island Light.
Cedar Island Light
Lighthouse · 2.1 mi SE
Cedar Island Light is a lighthouse in Cedar Point County Park in East Hampton, New York. It overlooks Gardiners Bay.
Orient Long Beach Bar Light is a lighthouse off Orient, New York. It was originally a screwpile lighthouse that was later converted to concrete caisson foundation. Its early appearance as a screwpile lighthouse gave it…
Horton Point Light is a lighthouse on the north side of Eastern Long Island, New York in the hamlet of Southold. The lighthouse and the grounds surrounding it are under the supervision of the Town of Southold Park…
Plum Island Light is located on the western end of Plum Island, which lies in the Long Island Sound, east of Orient Point at the end of the North Fork of Long Island, New York. A historic granite lighthouse originally…
Orient Point Light is a sparkplug lighthouse off Orient Point, New York in Plum Gut of Long Island Sound – the deep and narrow gap between Orient Point and Plum Island. It was built in 1899 and was automated in 1954.…
Plum Island Light is located on the western end of Plum Island, which lies in the Long Island Sound, east of Orient Point at the end of the North Fork of Long Island, New York. A historic granite lighthouse originally…
Fort Terry was a coastal fortification on Plum Island, a small island just off Orient Point, New York, United States. This strategic position afforded it a commanding view over the Atlantic entrance to the commercially…
Saybrook Breakwater Lighthouse is a sparkplug lighthouse in Connecticut,
United States, at Fenwick Point at the mouth of the Connecticut River near Old Saybrook, Connecticut. It is featured on the state's "Preserve the…
Parks and gardens near Shelter Island: there are 4 on our list. The most popular is Orient Beach State Park (5.4 mi N), followed by Hither Hills State Park, Napeague State Park and Cedar Point County Park.
Orient Beach State Park
State park · 5.4 mi N
Orient Beach State Park is a 363-acre (1.47 km2) state park located in Southold, New York. The park is situated at the tip of the North Fork of Long Island.
Long Beach, located within the park, was designated a National…
Hither Hills State Park is a 7.1-square-kilometre (2.7 sq mi) state park located on the eastern end of the South Fork of Long Island near the hamlet of Montauk, New York.
Napeague State Park is a 1,364-acre (5.52 km2) state park in the town of East Hampton in Suffolk County, New York. The largely undeveloped park stretches across the entire narrow width of the South Fork of Long Island…
Cedar Point County Park is a 607-acre (246 ha) park in East Hampton, New York, owned by the government of Suffolk County, New York. It has commanding views of Gardiners Bay and is famed for its decommissioned…
Nature reserves & natural wonders near Shelter Island
Nature reserves, caves and natural wonders near Shelter Island: there are 10 on our list. The most popular is Elizabeth Alexandra Morton National Wildlife Refuge (5.2 mi SW), followed by Gardiners Island, Conscience Point National Wildlife Refuge and Amagansett National Wildlife Refuge.
Elizabeth Alexandra Morton National Wildlife Refuge
Wildlife refuge · 5.2 mi SW
The Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge is a 187-acre (76 ha) National Wildlife Refuge in Noyack, New York. Much of the refuge is situated on a peninsula surrounded by Noyack and Little Peconic bays. The refuge…
Gardiner's Island is a small island in the Town of East Hampton, New York, in Eastern Suffolk County. It is located in Gardiner's Bay between the two peninsulas at the east end of Long Island. It is 6 miles (9.7 km)…
The Conscience Point National Wildlife Refuge was established July 20, 1971, as a land gift from Stanley Howard. The 60-acre (24 ha) refuge is located in the hamlet of North Sea, New York, on the north shore of Long…
The Amagansett National Wildlife Refuge, in Amagansett, New York, is located along the shore of the Atlantic Ocean on Long Island's south fork. The refuge is managed by the United States Fish and Wildlife Service as…
Plum Island is an island in the town of Southold in Suffolk County, New York. The island is situated in Gardiners Bay, east of Orient Point, off the eastern end of the North Fork coast of Long Island. It is about 3…
Cartwright Island (also known as Cartwright Shoal) exists as a long, narrow, segmented sandbar, separated from the south end of historic Gardiner's Island, off the coast of Long Island, New York. An analysis of…
Gardiners Point Island is an island in Block Island Sound, New York, that was the former location of the Gardiners Island Lighthouse as well as Fort Tyler. Once a peninsula of Gardiners Island – permanently detached in…
Robins Island is a 435-acre (1.76 km2) island in Peconic Bay by the eastern end of Long Island off the coast of New Suffolk, New York. The island is privately owned and not accessible to the public and is within the…
Theaters and public art near Shelter Island: there are 2 on our list. The most popular is The Watermill Center (10 mi S), followed by The Hedgehog and the Fox.
The Watermill Center
Theater · 10 mi S
The Watermill Center is a center for the arts and humanities in Water Mill, New York, founded in 1992 by artist and theater director Robert Wilson.
The Hedgehog and the Fox is a late Minimalist sculpture of Richard Serra, installed between Peyton and Fine halls and the football stadium at Princeton University in 2000. It was commissioned for the university by…
Golf, marinas & outdoor sports near Shelter Island
Golf courses, marinas and sports venues near Shelter Island: there are 3 on our list. The most popular is Shinnecock Hills Golf Club (13 mi SW), followed by Sag Harbor State Golf Course and National Golf Links of America.
Shinnecock Hills Golf Club
Golf course · 13 mi SW
Shinnecock Hills Golf Club is a links-style golf club located in the Shinnecock Hills section of Southampton, New York on Long Island, situated between the Peconic Bay and the Atlantic Ocean. Founded in 1891, it is one…
The Sag Harbor State Golf Course is 48.8-acre (197,000 m2), 9-hole golf course, located in the middle of a 341-acre (1.38 km2) parcel known as the Barcelona Neck Natural Resources Management Area. The golf course is…
National Golf Links of America is a links-style golf course in Southampton, New York, located on Long Island between Shinnecock Hills Golf Club and Peconic Bay. Though the course is noted for hosting the initial Walker…
What are the best things to do in Shelter Island, NY?
The top things to do in Shelter Island are Orient Beach State Park, Railroad Museum of Long Island, Cedar Island Light, Sag Harbor Whaling Museum and Orient Long Beach Bar Light. In total there are 35 attractions, parks and places to visit within 15 miles.
What is Shelter Island, NY known for?
Shelter Island is best known for Orient Beach State Park and Railroad Museum of Long Island (state park in Suffolk County, New York, United States). Visitors also come for its parks & gardens, museums & galleries, historic sites & landmarks.
What are some free things to do in Shelter Island?
Free things to do in Shelter Island include Orient Beach State Park, Hither Hills State Park, Napeague State Park and Cedar Point County Park.
What can you do with kids in Shelter Island?
With children, try Railroad Museum of Long Island, Sag Harbor Whaling Museum, Parrish Art Museum and Dia Bridgehampton.
What to do in Shelter Island on a rainy day?
On a rainy day, head indoors to Railroad Museum of Long Island, Sag Harbor Whaling Museum, Parrish Art Museum and Dia Bridgehampton.
What museums are in Shelter Island?
Museums and galleries in and near Shelter Island: Railroad Museum of Long Island, Sag Harbor Whaling Museum, Parrish Art Museum and Dia Bridgehampton.
When is the best time to visit Shelter Island?
The best time to visit Shelter Island is June to September, when the weather is most pleasant according to NOAA 1991–2020 climate normals.
Is Shelter Island, NY worth visiting?
Yes, if you like parks & gardens and museums & galleries. With 35 places to visit nearby, plan 1–2 days to see the highlights.
How many days do you need in Shelter Island?
One or two days is enough to see the main sights of Shelter Island, including Orient Beach State Park, Railroad Museum of Long Island and Cedar Island Light.