Living in Shelter Island, New York

Cost of living, income, home prices, rent and demographics of Shelter Island · Census data 2020–2024

Shelter Island has 2,125 residents with a median age of 41.3. The median household income is $165,734 (93% higher than the New York median), the median home value is $1,025,400.

Shelter Island at a glance

Population
2,125
Median age
41.3State: 39.8
Median household income
$165,734State: $85,974
Median home value
$1,025,400State: $423,800
Homeowners
89.3%
Bachelor's degree or higher
56%
Average commute
41 min

Is Shelter Island a good place to live?

Pros: Median household income 93% higher than the New York median; unemployment of 5.3%; a poverty rate of 0.9%.

Cons: Home values 142% higher than the state median; an average commute of 41 minutes.

Shelter Island has 35 parks, attractions and places to visit nearby. The weather is best in June to September.

Cost of living in Shelter Island

Housing is the biggest part of the cost of living. In Shelter Island the median home value is $1,025,400, 208% higher than the U.S. median. Renters pay a median of — per month. Homeowners with a mortgage pay $2,904 a month in housing costs.

Median home value

Shelter Island$1,025,400
New York$423,800
United States$332,700

Median monthly rent

New York$1,621
United States$1,413

Shelter Island median household income

The median household income in Shelter Island is $165,734 and the income per person is $58,080. 0.9% of residents live below the poverty line (New York: 14%).

Median household income

Shelter Island$165,734
New York$85,974
United States$80,734

Housing in Shelter Island: homes for sale and rent

Housing units
1,410
Owner-occupied
89.3%
Renter-occupied
10.7%
Vacant
51.6%Includes seasonal homes
Median year built
1974
Average household size
3.11

51.6% of homes are vacant most of the year, a sign that Shelter Island has many vacation and second homes.

Shelter Island demographics

Population
2,125
Median age
41.3
Under 18
27.3%
65 and older
18.7%
Households
683
Foreign-born
16.6%
Veterans
0%Adults 18+

Race and ethnicity

White57%
Hispanic or Latino31.8%
Black0%
Asian0%

Hispanic or Latino can be of any race. Population history of Shelter Island ›

Education in Shelter Island

56% of adults 25 and older in Shelter Island have a bachelor's degree or higher (New York: 40.2%), and 25.8% have a graduate or professional degree.

Bachelor's degree or higher

Shelter Island56%
New York40.2%
United States35.7%

Jobs and commute in Shelter Island

Unemployment rate
5.3%State: 6.4%
Average commute
41 minState: 33 min
Work from home
25.1%
Drive alone
48.1%
Public transit
20%
Walk to work
0%
Homes with broadband
47.6%

Shelter Island vs nearby towns

TownPopulationMedian incomeHome valueRent
Shelter Island2,125$165,734$1,025,400—
North Haven967$154,653$1,916,700—
Shelter Island Heights1,230$113,091$1,157,200—
Sag Harbor2,489$129,821$1,615,900$3,501
Greenport2,574$81,094$961,200$2,104
Northwest Harbor5,205$160,375$1,573,300$1,807
Greenport West2,463$93,983$839,900$1,979
Noyack4,782$118,728$1,085,500$2,369
East Marion1,331$102,500$857,800—

More for people moving to Shelter Island

Shelter Island ZIP code ›Weather and climate ›

Living in Shelter Island: FAQ

What is the median household income in Shelter Island, NY?

The median household income in Shelter Island is $165,734, 93% higher than the New York median of $85,974 (U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates 2020–2024).

What is the average home price in Shelter Island?

The median home value in Shelter Island is $1,025,400, compared with $423,800 in New York.

Is Shelter Island, NY a good place to live?

Pluses: median household income 93% higher than the New York median; unemployment of 5.3%; a poverty rate of 0.9%. Minuses: home values 142% higher than the state median; an average commute of 41 minutes.

What is the median age in Shelter Island?

The median age in Shelter Island is 41.3 years (New York: 39.8).

How long is the commute in Shelter Island?

The average commute to work in Shelter Island is 41 minutes; 25.1% of workers work from home.

What is the unemployment rate in Shelter Island?

The unemployment rate in Shelter Island is 5.3% (U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates 2020–2024).

How educated is Shelter Island?

56% of adults in Shelter Island have a bachelor's degree or higher.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates 2020–2024 (margins of error apply, especially in small towns). Figures are in 2024 dollars.

Last updated: