Schools in Shelter Island, NY

Public elementary, middle and high schools in and near Shelter Island, New York · 2024–25 school year

Shelter Island has 1 public school with about 183 students and 5.1 students per teacher. The nearest high school is PIERSON MIDDLE/HIGH SCHOOL, 4.2 mi S.

Shelter Island schools at a glance

Public schools
1
Students
183
Teachers (FTE)
36
Students per teacher
5.1
Other schools
1

Elementary schools near Shelter Island

The closest elementary school is SAG HARBOR ELEMENTARY SCHOOL, 4.1 mi S.

SchoolGradesStudentsStudents per teacherTypeDistance
SAG HARBOR ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Sag Harbor · SAG HARBOR UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–54318.8Public4.1 mi S
GREENPORT ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Greenport · GREENPORT UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–632712.1Public4.9 mi NW
OYSTERPONDS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Orient · OYSTERPONDS UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–6866.6Public6.1 mi N
SOUTHOLD ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Southold · SOUTHOLD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
K–63048.2Public6.9 mi W
SPRINGS SCHOOL
East Hampton · SPRINGS UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–869014.7Public7.8 mi E
JOHN M MARSHALL ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
East Hampton · EAST HAMPTON UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–55179.9Public8.4 mi SE
WAINSCOTT SCHOOL
Wainscott · WAINSCOTT COMMON SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–5217.0Public8.7 mi S
SAGAPONACK SCHOOL
Sagaponack · SAGAPONACK COMMON SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–3178.5Public8.7 mi S
MATTITUCK-CUTCHOGUE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Cutchogue · MATTITUCK-CUTCHOGUE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
K–64577.7Public9.3 mi W
AMAGANSETT SCHOOL
Amagansett · AMAGANSETT UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–81126.2Public9.9 mi SE
TUCKAHOE SCHOOL
Southampton · TUCKAHOE COMMON SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–82497.5Public12 mi SW
SOUTHAMPTON ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Southampton · SOUTHAMPTON UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–43648.5Public13 mi S

Middle schools near Shelter Island

The closest middle school is EAST HAMPTON MIDDLE SCHOOL, 8.4 mi SE.

SchoolGradesStudentsStudents per teacherTypeDistance
EAST HAMPTON MIDDLE SCHOOL
East Hampton · EAST HAMPTON UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
6–82847.9Public8.4 mi SE
SOUTHAMPTON INTERMEDIATE SCHOOL
Southampton · SOUTHAMPTON UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
5–83246.6Public12 mi S

High schools near Shelter Island

The closest high school is PIERSON MIDDLE/HIGH SCHOOL, 4.2 mi S.

SchoolGradesStudentsStudents per teacherTypeDistance
PIERSON MIDDLE/HIGH SCHOOL
Sag Harbor · SAG HARBOR UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
6–125016.9Public4.2 mi S
GREENPORT HIGH SCHOOL
Greenport · GREENPORT UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
7–123589.7Public4.9 mi NW
SOUTHOLD JUNIOR-SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
Southold · SOUTHOLD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
7–123337.9Public7.0 mi W
EAST HAMPTON HIGH SCHOOL
East Hampton · EAST HAMPTON UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
9–121,06912.0Public7.8 mi SE
SOUTHAMPTON HIGH SCHOOL
Southampton · SOUTHAMPTON UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
9–125828.6Public12 mi S
MATTITUCK JUNIOR-SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
Mattituck · MATTITUCK-CUTCHOGUE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
7–125248.9Public13 mi W

Other schools in Shelter Island

Shelter Island has 1 school.

SchoolGradesStudentsStudents per teacherTypeDistance
SHELTER ISLAND SCHOOL
Shelter Island · SHELTER ISLAND UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–121835.1Public2.3 mi W
BRIDGEHAMPTON SCHOOL
Bridgehampton · BRIDGEHAMPTON UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT
PK–121854.4Public8.1 mi S

Map of schools in Shelter Island

Tap a place on the map to see it in Street View below. Map: © OpenStreetMap contributors.

Shelter Island Street View

Loading Street View…

Drag to look around. Tap any place on the map above, or the "Street View" button on a card, to jump there.

Open in Google Maps ›

Schools in Shelter Island: FAQ

How many public schools are in Shelter Island, NY?

Shelter Island has 1 public schools with about 183 students.

What high school do students in Shelter Island attend?

The nearest is PIERSON MIDDLE/HIGH SCHOOL, 4.2 mi S. School assignment depends on your address: check with SAG HARBOR UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT.

What is the middle school in Shelter Island?

The nearest is EAST HAMPTON MIDDLE SCHOOL, 8.4 mi SE. School assignment depends on your address: check with EAST HAMPTON UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT.

What elementary schools are in Shelter Island?

The nearest is SAG HARBOR ELEMENTARY SCHOOL, 4.1 mi S. School assignment depends on your address: check with SAG HARBOR UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT.

Are there charter schools in Shelter Island?

There are no public charter schools in or near Shelter Island in the federal school directory.

What is the largest school in Shelter Island?

EAST HAMPTON HIGH SCHOOL, with 1,069 students (grades 9–12).

Source: U.S. Department of Education, NCES Common Core of Data (2024–25), via the Urban Institute Education Data Portal. Public schools only. Distances in a straight line from the center of Shelter Island. School attendance zones depend on your street address: confirm with the school district.

Last updated: